mjj (flemmings) wrote,
mjj
flemmings

Got Licensed to Quill and had a look at the first few pages. Not nearly as bad as I feared- its diction not even as breezily 20C as Cue for Treason's-- but it does one thing that always gets up my nose. Characters are made to say famous Shakespearean lines long before he wrote them. I can't think why people do this. It's too obvious to be a shout-out: everyone knows 'To be or not to be' is from Hamlet. Or maybe they don't. Maybe it *is* a shout-out. Or maybe the author thinks it clever or witty. I really don't know,

(Antonia Forest fanficcers are tiresomely prone to the same thing. It's as if someone's manner of speaking has been set in concrete by the author and the characters will echo their teenaged selves twenty and thirty years later. Which, yanno, one would hope not.)

And I'm not convinced the whole of the acting troupe would take exception to the anachronistic mention of a clock in Julius Caesar and wonder why they weren't wearing historically appropriate bedsheet togas instead of their everyday wear. I should look this up, but did even the 18th century have a notion of anachronism? (Google. Wiki says the awareness and reaction to it dates from late 18C, but gives no citation.)

Meanwhile I need to finish The Younger Edda even if it makes my head spin. Norse/ Icelandic mythology is a mess, and constructing a coherent narrative from it seems rather like establishing the text of a Sumerian work from a bunch of shattered clay tablets. Probably one shouldn't even try, but just enjoy he moments of 'so *that's* where Tolkien got that name!'
Tags: reading_16, shakespeare
Subscribe

  • 'Been there, done that, read The Silmarillion'

    As someone said about similar circumstances to my own. So, I've finally read The Silmarillion, AKA 'why we can't have nice things', as well as most…

  • Mph

    It was snowing last week and my recycle bin was only half full, so I didn't put it out then, and two weeks ago my garbage bag was only half full, so…

  • (no subject)

    Coworker said the women at her gym swear by THC balm from some west coast firm, so I ordered a jar, which arrived today as I was limping upstairs…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 0 comments