mjj (flemmings) wrote,
mjj
flemmings

A Downer is an Upper?

Finished The Knife of Never Letting Go at 2 am last night. Short term- yes, gotta find out what happens. Long term- why does anyone read dystopia? Why is there so *much* YA dystopia? (There was an article about that somewhere.) I suppose it's a corrective to the mandatory happi endo of kids' books. Today you are a man, so now you can read books where the hero and his entire family die, as well as the dogs and horses. (Actually, isn't that Njal's Saga? But why would you read Njal's Saga either.)

Certainly has echoes of Riddley Walker: premature (by our standards) adulthood, dialect, post-catastrophe world. Of course RW is a tour-de-force and much more opaque than Knife: I wasn't entirely sure what was happening / had happened much of the time, and needed the Coles' Notes to help me out. Knife lays things out for you, as you would expect, even if it takes forever to do so. Among the irritations was the 'every time someone's about to tell Todd the truth, they're interrupted by some new threat.' The other irritation (aside form what one reviewer called 'Aaron the Energizer Bunny' and I mean *really*. Is the man a cyborg? a zombie? a character in Angel Sanctuary?) is if the women are immune to this germ, why does it make them passively psychic? They can hear but not be heard. That's not immunity; it's a selective infection.
Tags: reading_15
Subscribe

  • Happy new year, says Eeyore

    2013 was generally better than 2012 which was infinitely better than 2011 which was arguably better than 2010. 2013 still wasn't outstandingly good…

  • Time travel

    Christmas season is bad enough for scrambling the time sense. But having two days off smack in the middle of the week, which we haven't done in…

  • (sings) You warm up my life...

    I'm not a fan of the strollers they make for little babies. They're basically frames for holding hard-edged baby car seats: they're heavy and…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 0 comments