mjj (flemmings) wrote,

Spent thirty minutes in a fruitless google trying to discover when the desu-masu verb form ending began in spoken Japanese. Then spent another thirty minutes reading a fascinating if frustrating text version of An Historical Grammar of Japanese. (Fascinating because it's the classical stuff I learned twenty-five years ago and never got straight even then; frustrating because text versions don't reproduce kanji.) If Edo yakuza speech in Mito Komon is at all historically accurate, which one doubts, then -masu starts pretty early on. Maybe by Bakumatsu it might be as it is today.

But I *still* don't think, Mr Gibson, that one would effect an introduction in the 1850s in exactly the same language one would use a hundred and fifty years later. It feels nowhere near polite enough, though I'm damned if I know what you'd say instead. That super-polite level that I only heard now and again, from older women talking about CEOs, maybe. Or maybe it's a level that disappeared with the war and I've never heard it at all.
Tags: japanese, reading_13

  • She considers the year past

    I'm very sorry so many people seem to have had a frightful year last year. I had a wonderful year, in keeping with my habit of having wonderful years…

  • As New Year's approaches

    So if my birthday book is correct, yesterday was joasakura's birthday and today is stanking's, and I hope both your years are…

  • (no subject)

    I'm cooking a turkey because Christmas is all about bread stuffing and cranberry sauce where I come from, and I thought it was a small turkey- 9 lbs…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded