mjj (flemmings) wrote,

What this book needs is a fact-checking Brit-picker

My confidence in the editors of Holmes pastiche is not strengthened when I find Holmes and Watson taking 'a transom' to reach their destination, not once but several times. The author shouldn't have written that, but the editors-- to say nothing of the named betas-- should certainly have caught it.

Which goes double for Holmes' account of a peer of the Welsh marches murdered in 1687 by his wife and daughters. "...the local population didn't regard Rupert Grimsley's murder as particularly evil; the villagers impeded the Metropolitan police in the pursuit of their duties to such effect that the three murderesses got completely away." The Metropolitan police, founded in 1829 and responsible for the city of London, would not have been active on the borders of Wales in the 17th century; and Barbara Hambly, who wrote that story, ought to have known as much.
Tags: holmes, reading_13

  • I was a free man in Paris

    Twenty years ago I was in Tokyo, staying at the swanky US forces hotel with its breakfast buffet (all the bacon and sausage you can eat), buying out…

  • (no subject)

    Woke up at my once upon a time regular hour, which is 9:15, and for once was awake at that hour, no rolling over and sliding back to sleep, so for…

  • (no subject)

    My clean life resolution lasted about two days. It's obvious I'm not going to survive this winter without gin, because the acupuncture, muscle…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 1 comment