mjj (flemmings) wrote,
mjj
flemmings

Fantasy for those who hate fantasy

Top ten mould-breaking fantasy novels. As Tuttle says herself, "that sort of labelling implies there's a strong consensus view of what fantasy literature is, both among those who read it and those who wouldn't touch it with a barge pole." When people in the comments suggest Roger Zelazny, Stephen Donaldson, and Robin Hobb as further possibilities, I have to wonder what their consensus view of fantasy is. By my standards, all those are as western quasi-medieval derivative as anyone could wish. Maybe all they mean by 'not yer average fantasy' is 'not Sword of Shannara.'

Am pleased by the number of 'but what about Aaronovitch?' comments, though.

What have you just finished reading?
Caryl Brahms and SJ Simon, Don't, Mr Disraeli. Because the only library copy of No Bed for Bacon is non-circulating. Shall not be seeking that one out, I fancy. I'm not sure what the authors were trying for but I suspect, curmudgeonly, that they thought they were being brilliantly MAD!! young things. They do deserve props for being brilliantly MAD!! in the middle of the blitz, or possibly just before, but still. The introduction credits them with creating the genre of anachronistic humour and maybe they did. I can't myself think of anything that predates them. But for me, anachronistic humour works better in a visual context: Jarman's Caravaggio, say, or Python. As text- oh well. I didn't find it that funny, basically.

What are you reading now?
Patricia Briggs, Blood Bound. Vampires and werewolves *still*, but the protagonist is a spirit-walker, a coyote, and the writing is a cut above most other vampire and werewolf novels I can name, if not at the diverting level of Parasol Protectorate. It's still slow going, but that may be down to morning shifts and the brainlessness consequent on them. Also the truncated evenings, since one must be washed and in bed by 10:30 at the latest.

What will you read next?
I have two more Briggs if the first (second in the series, actually) amuses me, once I can sleep and the weather cools off. But there's also something In Transit from the library, and a Sugawara Akitada mystery I bought to read in hot weather.

What have you given up on?
Grass on the Wayside, I think. Determinedly miserable protagonist overwhelmed by his life and his family and his obligations and and and.
Tags: meme, reading, reading_13, rivers
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 12 comments