mjj (flemmings) wrote,
mjj
flemmings

I shall start a society for the preservation of Chinese characters...

I never got a handle on the whys and wherefores of hanzi/ kanji simplification, but I assumed it had to do with general standardization and, possibly, the promotion of universal literacy. Now I find my 1971 author blandly declaring that the Chinese government effected both simplification and pinyin as preliminary steps in the *abolition* of hanzi, and a move to a phonic western-alphabet-based writing system. (Which 1971 guy thinks is long overdue.) Was he totally on crack, as my reflexes say he must be, or is there something to this?

And I have to say, I do not get the character-hatred. The idea of reading Chinese in pinyin, even with tone markings, gives me the horrors. This is because I've read all hiragana Japanese and it's horrible. Horrible for the foreign reader, certainly; a native speaker might provide meaning and context by ear, but god knows I can't. So pace almost everyone I've read, dispensing with characters will *not* make reading easier for foreigners at all at all at all.

Also watched an hour of an NHK special on tea caravans that travel through Tibet. May rethink this taking ikkyuu business because dear god my ear (and my vocabulary) is so baaaad.
Tags: chinese, japanese
Subscribe

  • April 1, Acupuncture 0

    My last session left me limber for almost a week, but the April showers of yesterday and today, and tomorrow and Thursday as well probably, guarantee…

  • Would like to emulate my grandmother...

    ...and take to my bed for the rest of my life. Only she had servants and I do not. Eh well, got to the drugstore for Benadryl and Gravol so I'm…

  • (no subject)

    Managed to lose an expensive only available online leg brace sometime yesterday, possibly at the laundromat. It was only occasionally useful, is why…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 27 comments

  • April 1, Acupuncture 0

    My last session left me limber for almost a week, but the April showers of yesterday and today, and tomorrow and Thursday as well probably, guarantee…

  • Would like to emulate my grandmother...

    ...and take to my bed for the rest of my life. Only she had servants and I do not. Eh well, got to the drugstore for Benadryl and Gravol so I'm…

  • (no subject)

    Managed to lose an expensive only available online leg brace sometime yesterday, possibly at the laundromat. It was only occasionally useful, is why…